Fortified vs. Asphalt Shingles: A Comparison
Your roof is one of your most important home investments. You have many options when building or replacing a roof. Today, we compare fortified (polymer) shingles and asphalt (composition) shingles.
What are Fortified Shingles?
Fortified shingles consist of specialized polymers. These materials blend plastics and rubbers for maximum toughness and elasticity. Manufacturers use molds of real wood or stone to create a versatile, high-performance appearance.
What are Asphalt Shingles?
Asphalt shingles contain tar, fiberglass, and crushed stone granules. They come in three types: 3-tab, architectural, and luxury. Architectural shingles are the most popular because they mimic the look of wood shakes.
The Big Comparison
1. Curbside Appeal
Both options offer many colors and styles. However, fortified shingles emulate cedar and slate with much better detail. They use molds of real materials to achieve a more authentic look.
2. Lifetime Expectancy
Asphalt shingles typically last 25–30 years. Fortified shingles are expected to endure for around 50 years. Correct installation of all components ensures your roof reaches its full lifespan.
3. Warranty Options
Asphalt roofs usually carry a 25–30 year warranty. Certified contractors can often extend this to 50 years. Most synthetic manufacturers offer a 50-year warranty on the product itself.
4. The Cost Difference
Every roof varies in cost based on its pitch and complexity. You will pay more upfront for a fortified roof than an asphalt roof.
Estimated Asphalt Costs:
-
1,500 sq ft: $12,500 – $19,500
-
2,500 sq ft: $19,500 – $25,500
-
3,500 sq ft: $25,500 – $32,500
Estimated Fortified Costs:
-
1,500 sq ft: $16,000 – $22,000
-
2,500 sq ft: $22,000 – $35,000
-
3,500 sq ft: $35,000 – $45,000
Asphalt costs less now but requires more frequent repairs and earlier replacement.
Protect Your Shell with Roofing Turtle
Roofing Turtle specializes in Texas-made fortified shingles. Our products carry a Class 4 Impact Rating and a Class A Fire Rating.
We also install traditional asphalt, metal, and commercial TPO roofing. Get the last roof you will ever need! Call us at 1-833-688-7853 or request a quote online today.